Current:Home > MarketsMarathon Reaches Deal with Investors on Human Rights. Standing Rock Hoped for More. -FinanceMind
Marathon Reaches Deal with Investors on Human Rights. Standing Rock Hoped for More.
View
Date:2025-04-14 14:30:02
In the face of mounting pressure from investors and the glare of public scrutiny, Marathon Petroleum Corp. officials acknowledged that the company has a responsibility to address environmental and social risks—including potential violations of the rights of indigenous people.
However, in an agreement signed Friday with a block of shareholders, the oil company also said that the ultimate responsibility for protecting human rights lies with government regulators. Human rights activists described the concessions as superficial and said the lack of binding requirements could allow the company to continue with little reform.
Shareholders in the Ohio-based company turned up the heat after seeing the treatment of the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe and others protesting the Dakota Access pipeline, a project Marathon bought into just as tensions were boiling over in 2016.
A group of shareholders led by the New York State Comptroller’s Office filed a resolution pressing the company to consider environmental and human rights issues when assessing risks associated with acquisitions, and to report back on those practices.
“The construction and operation of energy infrastructure in North America requires respect for rigorous standards of environmental review and the human rights of Indigenous Peoples,” the resolution states.
Under the agreement, the resolution will be withdrawn once the company makes good on its pledge to add a topic—“Human Rights and Core Values”—to its website to address the issue. The company said this will enhance disclosures that include how its values and conduct relate to indigenous people and the environment.
The company also promised to include in its annual Citizenship Report a section addressing social matters that is consistent with the United Nations guidelines addressing the rights of indigenous people.
“We respect the human, cultural and legal rights of all individuals and communities,” Marathon said in the agreement. “Our commitment extends to the fair treatment and meaningful involvement of all people, including indigenous people, regardless of race, color, national origin or income level.”
Marathon: Government Is Responsible for Protecting Human Rights
Yet the company says much of the responsibility for protecting human rights and ensuring the rights of indigenous people in the United States rests with federal and state governments.
“There are robust permitting processes for energy facility and infrastructure projects that provide a means of public comment and participation, and judicial oversight is of course a hallmark of our domestic system of government,” the company says in the agreement.
A spokesman for Marathon did not respond to a request to elaborate.
Shareholders Say It’s ‘A Step Forward’
Although not a complete victory for the shareholders, the comptroller’s office said the agreement represents “a step forward.”
“The company has publicly acknowledged its corporate responsibility above and beyond the legal requirements imposed by federal and state governments,” said Matthew Sweeney, assistant communications director for New York State Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli.
“It has also agreed to ongoing dialogue with stakeholders concerning the issues raised by the resolution,” he said. “We will continue to work with stakeholders to hold the company accountable for the impact of its operations.”
Human Rights Activists Disagree
It’s a superficial agreement that does not make a genuine commitment to addressing the rights of indigenous people, said Jodi Gillette, a member of the Standing Rock tribe and former adviser to President Barack Obama on Native American affairs.
She also called it disingenuous for Marathon to say the federal government will act as a check-and-balance. Federal authorities ultimately approved the Dakota Access pipeline route without having to consult the tribe, she said.
“If Marathon Petroleum continues down the path of assuming the United States will respect our people, then their current course of action is insufficient and unfortunately will result in future dehumanization of indigenous people,” Gillette said.
She said she appreciates the willingness of Marathon to engage on issues relevant to indigenous people, but there has to be some assurance it’s more than just talk.
Marathon Fought Resolution Last Year
The company fought a similar resolution last year that nonetheless gained approval from 35 percent of its shareholders.
Preparing the kind of reports sought through that 2017 resolution would have required a carefully tailored study of projects under consideration, the company argued in its proxy statement at the time. “Providing a report of the nature the proponent seeks would require [Marathon] to present an incomplete and potentially misleading picture of prospective strategic transactions,” Marathon said.
The company reasoned that its community engagement program provided a forum and allowed adequate opportunity for any group to make criticisms known, according to the proxy statement.
Along with holding the company accountable for human rights, shareholders feared any future confrontations, such as happened with the Standing Rock tribe over construction of the Dakota Access pipeline, could damage Marathon’s reputation, resulting in a loss of stock value.
In partnership with Enbridge, Inc., Marathon bought a minority interest in the Bakken pipeline system that included Dakota Access as tensions between pipeline opponents and backers were rising.
Shareholders in Enbridge, a Canadian pipeline company that owns more than 10,000 miles of pipelines in Canada and the United States, filed a similar resolution last year. Although the resolution was defeated, the company said it would expand its disclosures to shareholders about how it addresses human rights and indigenous people.
veryGood! (2)
Related
- The city of Chicago is ordered to pay nearly $80M for a police chase that killed a 10
- Bill Belichick's most eye-popping stats and records from his 24 years with the Patriots
- Google should pay a multibillion fine in antitrust shopping case, an EU court adviser says
- Hundreds of manatees huddle together for warmth at Three Sisters Springs in Florida: Watch
- John Galliano out at Maison Margiela, capping year of fashion designer musical chairs
- Recalled charcuterie meats from Sam's Club investigated for links to salmonella outbreak in 14 states
- US adults across racial groups agree the economy is a top priority, AP-NORC and AAPI Data polls show
- Clarins 24-Hour Flash Deal— Get 50% off the Mask That Depuffs My Skin in Just 10 Minutes
- Person accused of accosting Rep. Nancy Mace at Capitol pleads not guilty to assault charge
- After 2 nominations, Angela Bassett wins an honorary Oscar
Ranking
- Bill Belichick's salary at North Carolina: School releases football coach's contract details
- Nick Saban retiring as Alabama football coach
- Researchers identify a fossil unearthed in New Mexico as an older, more primitive relative of T. rex
- Why Golden Bachelor's Leslie Was Uncomfortable During Gerry and Theresa's Wedding
- Friday the 13th luck? 13 past Mega Millions jackpot wins in December. See top 10 lottery prizes
- Biden meets with Paul Whelan's sister after Russia rejects offer to free him
- Archeologists map lost cities in Ecuadorian Amazon, settlements that lasted 1,000 years
- Fewer police officers died in the line of duty in 2023, but 'scary number' were shot: Study
Recommendation
Travis Hunter, the 2
These Best Dressed Stars at the Emmys Deserve a Standing Ovation for Their Award-Worthy Style
Manifest Everything You Want for 2024 With These Tips From Camille Kostek
NYC issues vacate orders to stabilize historic Jewish sites following discovery of 60-foot tunnel
Trump wants to turn the clock on daylight saving time
Every Browns starting quarterback since their NFL return in 1999
Lake Powell Is Still in Trouble. Here’s What’s Good and What’s Alarming About the Current Water Level
US and allies accuse Russia of using North Korean missiles against Ukraine, violating UN sanctions